Get Your Free Week Trial Today! | 317-407-4512
BLOG

CrossFit DOES NOT mean Paleo

This is not a dogmatic nutrition post. I am not going to spend the next 500 to 1000 words shouting at you through the computer about why you should eat in a particular way, or why what you had for breakfast this morning is totally going to kill you/make you fat/smash your gainzzz/whatever. My only goal here is to dispel the notion that everyone who CrossFits treats carbs like the devil and obsesses over whether or not a caveman could have eaten the food on their plate.

I actually used to think this was the case, at least in theory. I had been around enough CrossFit athletes inside and outside of boxes to know that they did not all eat paleo. Of course, some did, and as with most nutrition plans, those that followed it well had great results. I remember one guy, Todd, at my box in Tampa who was probably 10-15 years older than I am, and still looked like he was maybe late twenties. He ate pretty strict paleo from what I could tell. However, others (myself included) sort of stuck one toe in the water. I didn’t want to drink the Kool-Aid so hard and just become a total “CrossFit Bro” in year one. Know what I’m saying? But still, in the back of my mind, I thought that everyone who was a “serious CrossFit athlete” was recommended to eat strict paleo style. When I went to Chicago to get my CrossFit Level 1, I was taught just how wrong that assumption was.

CrossFit Level 1 Training – Nutrition Section

I had looked over the itinerary for the weekend, and I was as excited for the nutrition portion of the seminar as any. I really enjoy learning about the way food can help and hurt our bodies, and I was excited to see how the CrossFit Seminar Staff addressed the legitimate concern that the paleo diet was severely lacking in carbohydrates for an athlete aspiring to perform at their highest. Unfortunately, as we sat down to start the lecture, I knew immediately I wasn’t going to hear about that. I actually wasn’t going to be preached to about the benefits of the paleo diet. I wasn’t going to be told how that white rice was going to kill me, or that I had to cut specific things out of my diet immediately. The truth is that CrossFit HQ doesn’t even propose to follow the paleo diet. Technically, the nutrition plan they espouse is the Zone Diet. Now, I have an entire list of issues with the Zone plan, namely that its so deficient in calories that many people simply under-eat, but still, it wasn’t Paleo. So what’s the deal??

“Eat meat and vegetables, nuts and seeds, some fruit and a little starch.” That’s the quote in the CrossFit handbook about how to eat. Doesn’t really go into that many details, does it? It gives a broad explanation of what CrossFit founder Greg Glassman believes is best to eat, but it doesn’t really give a restriction on caloric content, how much of each macronutrient, when to eat them, etc. etc. etc. Seems surprisingly lenient, actually, given what many people think of when they imagine CrossFit.

Why does everyone think CrossFit = Paleo?

People, in general, like to be able to follow a checklist. Life is a lot easier when we can act in black and whites. That’s why we follow specific lesson plans for school, processes for work, and nutrition plans that clearly indicate what you can and cannot eat. Even on If it Fits Your Macros, you’re told what you can eat. Namely everything. As long as it fits, you’re good! But there’s your constraint. It must fit inside of your allotted carbs, proteins, fats, and calories for the day. In my opinion, that is why CrossFit goes with Zone. That gives structure to an otherwise ambiguous sentence. Eat those things, but make them fit inside of the Zone parameters, basically.

However, what if we took that sentence and just ran with it, forming it to fit some scientific principles? I’ve gone over this in detail in many other posts, but the First Law of Thermodynamics applies to nutrition. This means that if you eat too many calories, you’re going to gain weight. I’ve yet to see anyone disprove this fact. Of course, finding out how many calories to eat is pretty tough. I recommend either going to a lab and getting your Base Metabolic Rate (BMR) taken, then adding approximately 300-400 calories for a standard CrossFit workout. Or, you can weigh yourself a couple of times per week for a few weeks while measuring your food and also get a good estimation. Either way, calories are always going to matter.

That being said, I also don’t believe that all calories are created equal. Many nutrition plans that are concerned with macro nutrients are only concerned with you getting that number. Doesn’t matter whether that is Twinkies and low-quality peanut butter or whole grains, vegetables, and meat. On the flip side, those nutrition plans focused on always getting quality food sources often don’t care if you’re overeating your fats by 40 grams per day (that’s 360 calories for those keeping track). So, what if we combined the best of both worlds? What would happen?

I’m sure many people have already done this, but for the month of March I’m going to do a little experiment. I’m going to follow the CrossFit statement about what to eat, and I’m going to follow science in terms of how much to eat. I’ll write another post detailing what I’m going to do, and then I’ll do a write up each week detailing how I’m feeling, how training is going in terms of performance, and any noticeable changes in body composition I’m seeing. Hopefully it will be interesting and we’ll all learn something.

Other Posts You Might Like

Why am I not losing weight?

“Why am I not losing weight?” How many times have you asked yourself, your best friend (they’re tired of you asking, by the way) or even your coach this question? To be honest, we hear this sometimes. Usually it is from someone who just started CrossFit and hasn’t really given the time for results to … more »

Am I ready for CrossFit?

We are asked, “Am I ready for CrossFit?” multiple times every week. The knee jerk reaction is to say yes. Then I got to thinking if that’s really true, or not. The biggest cliche in CrossFit is that everyone can do CrossFit. Ask any well-intentioned, experienced CrossFit coach or athlete and they will say, “CrossFit … more »

10 Fat Loss Tips

I had an interesting conversation with a client the other day, and I believe many of us can identify with the same goal they shared. This person told me they had been battling the feeling that looking better really is a major reason they workout. This being part of the why behind their effort made … more »

WOD for Julie & the Fight Against Colon Cancer

This Saturday, April 13, 2019, the Summit Strength community along with athletes from other Indianapolis boxes, came together to honor the life and memory of Julie Mills, who is the inspiration behind the creation of Summit. Summit also accepted donations in support of the Colon Cancer Alliance, a leader in the fight against the disease. … more »

Achieve Your Goal

There’s a reason you hire a coach – which is what you’re doing when you join our box – and it is to achieve your goals. If you could accomplish everything you want on your own, there would not be a reason for you to work with us. The biggest mistake I see when working … more »

Disciplined Positivity

This weekend I was chatting with one of our members, Evan Nisonson, and he said something profound. “I think the key, really, is having disciplined positivity.” I have no idea where he first heard that term, but it is exactly the mindset we’re striving to achieve with our members at Summit. We focus on mindset … more »

Ready to transform your life?